What the public record says
Mayor Chad Givens, Mayor Pro Tem Gustavo Olvera, Council Member Gilbert T. Alvarado, Council Member Pete Espinoza, Council Member Cathy L. Prout is the holder text published for City Council.
That statement is limited to the dated CalRoster field supplied by City of Shafter. Election.org does not infer whether the position is elected or appointed, does not invent term dates, and does not treat the roster as a live feed.